Nakanomori BAND announced their breakup through their website on Sunday. News from Tokyograph here, and a reaction from pengie at unchained here. As a fan with all of their albums in my library, this is bad enough news to begin with. What makes this sadder is the breakup was precipitated by the forced layoff the band was under for the past couple of months because lead singer/guitarist Ayako Nakanomori at least a third of a way through a prescribed/predicted six-month recovery period following throat surgery; initially the other group members were going to tide themselves over with side projects until then, but now it seems that, unless that statement was a P.R. holding pattern, at least one person in the band changed their mind.
All musical instruments are fragile, from the oldest Stradivarius violin to the newest off-the-rack Fender Stratocaster. But the human larynx is the most fragile instrument of them all. The best way to combat or prevent such abuse is to learn how to sing from the diaphragm (chest voice) rather than from the voice box itself (head voice). Sometimes vocal training can actually help a person who tried to sing untrained recover or even improve their vocal power: In her pre-She’s So Unusual days, Cyndi Lauper rehabilitated her singing voice, which had been shredded from multiple nights fronting cover bands, by studying for a couple of years with a vocal coach who specialized in teaching rock and pop singers opera techniques. I think Henry Rollins underwent some similar vocal training in the mid-90’s, judging from the change his singing voice went through between the Weight album sessions in late 1993 and the Come In And Burn sessions in 1996. In between those two sessions, Rollins did a guest vocal on Mike Watt’s first solo album, but his voice is a rather harsh, throaty rasp on that track; his vocals from Come In And Burn onward have shown Rollins to be in much more control of his singing voice. At least one of his Rollins Band albums, Hard Volume, was recorded while the singer was both under deadline and suffering from strep throat, and his Black Flag diary/memoirs Get In The Van recounts several instances when he either blew his voice out onstage or did several consecutive weeks of one-nighters while battling laryngitis.
Of course, bad habits can also lead to the detriment and even the loss of vocal power. Smoking (both tobacco and marijuana) and drinking alcoholic beverages are the most common enemies of the voice box. Many singers - and rightfully so - prohibit people from smoking around them, but others will claim that smoking doesn’t effect their voices. In moderation, those vices may actually enhance some voices - Bob Dylan’s trademark vocal tone was partly the product of smoking both tobacco and pot, while a short layoff from lighting up led to the sweeter voice he had on his Nashville Skyline album. On the electronic press kit reproduced as a bonus feature on their When London Burns DVD, Deicide’s Glen Benton candidly credits the deepening octaves of his vocals to “cigarettes, Jack Daniels and marijuana” (vices he would give up in late 2006 on the advice of a doctor).
In excess,such vices can be fatal to the larynx: legendary operatic tenor Enrico Caruso smoked cigars regularly and paid the price of an onstage throat hemmorage for it, while on the totally opposite end of the spectrum, punk rock performance artist GG Allin, who started out his recording career in the late 1970’s with a more melodic, Iggy Pop and Stiv Bators-influenced vocal and delivery, recorded his final studio album with a voice that was horrifically ravaged from years of unrepentant drug and alcohol abuse. Even the casual use of cigarettes and alcohol can have fans of an artist up in arms, as Ai Kago’s original stalkerazzi-outed underage smoking incident in 2006 proved.
Diet can also have an effect, desired or not, on the voice. Many experts advise singers against consuming any kind of dairy product before recording or performing, owing to the buildup of mucus caused by even one glass of milk or slice of cheese. Of course, consuming the odd dairy product could also assist in deilbrately making a voice sound less worked on, something David Lee Roth (according to his own memoirs) discovered during the sessions for Van Halen’s first album. According to Roth’s memoir Crazy From The Heat, when their producer Ted Templeman discovered that Diamond Dave had avoided cigarettes and dairy prior to recording the lead vocal for “Jamie’s Cryin’”, Templeman ordered the singer to go outside and smoke a joint, and sent a studio runner out to get Roth a cheeseburger. Roth went outside, ate the cheeseburger, smoked half of the joint, drained a can of Coke, and came back in to record the vocal for one of VH’s best loved early album cuts.
I don’t know what kind of vocal training Ayako Nakanomori had (if any), or if she had any habits that could have resulted in her vocal problems. By that, I do not mean to imply that she was a smoker, only that she could have done or gone through other things, like poor diet choices, a stressful situation, or some sort of bad cold, that could have made her voice susceptible to getting a cyst on her vocal chords in the first place. Hopefully, she’ll overcome her original setback, just as she’ll have to overcome the sudden breakup of her eponymous band when she resumes her music career.